Monthly Archives: May 2008

May 6, 2008 · 1:05 pm

Gossip Girl – “All About My Brother”

“All About My Brother”

May 5th, 2008

It’s time for someone to be Outed – or, more accurately, for two people to be Outed. Homosexuality is one issue the series has not addressed in any broad strokes, and there is obvious concern when raising this that things will either fall into sensationalism or lack the emotional impact necessary to make this important issue resonate.

The series finds the perfect person to handle it, perhaps the show’s most sympathetic character. As everyone is busy being catty or bitchy, this character has never fallen into those traps, and it explains important things about his past and his future.

The result is an episode where homosexuality isn’t a joke, or a plot contrivance, but a real issue in a person’s life. Just as the show tackled pregnancy in the right way, I think they’re on the right path here as well…for the most part. The real problem is that while the end result might be fine, the way it’s used for the plot seems false by comparison.

Continue reading →

Leave a comment

Filed under Gossip Girl

Tagged as , ,

May 6, 2008 · 12:07 pm

Greek – “47 Hours and 11 Minutes”

“47 Hours and 11 Minutes”

May 5th, 2008

It’s “Meet the Parents” week on Greek, and I’ll admit that I wasn’t a huge fan of this one. Something about the various parents was just a bit too predictable: of course the Cartwrights are judgmental (Have you met their daughter?), of course Dale’s parents are overbearing, and of course Senator Logan is a cheating dirtbag because how else are we to start viewing his daughter as a sympathetic character?

The series is often mature beyond its appearance, but here it felt the exact opposite: an episode that appears on the surface to be a heartfelt realization of a parents’ love or a person’s own path is actually a validation of a vapid, twisted and totally unreasonable sibling perspective. I hated Casey in this episode, and by the end her behaviour was somehow “good” due to the end result. Call me a purist, but this “Ends Justify the Means” B.S. just isn’t going to cut it for me, not when the series already has issues with keeping her character within the likability window.

As a result, this episode was an exercise in my patience just as much as in the Freshmen with their parents in town.

Continue reading →

Leave a comment

Filed under Greek, Uncategorized

Tagged as , ,

May 6, 2008 · 2:05 am

How I Met Your Mother – “Rebound Bro”

“Rebound Bro”

May 5th, 2008

After last week’s breakup of Barney and Ted, it’s not easy being Barney…or Ted. Or Stella, the delightful girlfriend we’ve seen too little of since only now was Sarah Chalke able to make her return. And really, it’s a spiral for all of them, as they struggle with various hangups.

They’re realistic hangups – whether it’s Barney’s search for a wingman who isn’t married or taken, Ted struggling with two months of no sex with Stella, and Stella attempting to overcome her concerns over not having sex for five YEARS. The first certainly provides the most humour, in a traditional sense, but the others provide a less neurotic but more charming/dramatic turn.

It might not quite be comparable to next week, but who can complain about Virginity 2: Electric Bugaloo and an unexpected number of testacles?

Continue reading →

1 Comment

Filed under How I Met Your Mother

Tagged as , , , ,

May 5, 2008 · 9:59 pm

House – “Living the Dream”

“Living the Dream”

May 5th, 2008

On the list of storylines that I could have imagined for House, kidnapping his favourite soap star in order to diagnose the condition that he didn’t even know he had was not on the list. In a nice bit of foreshadowing, we saw the soap star last week, so we’re able to jump right into the story. And, well, it is an intriguing story.

Admittedly, House is a show that I never find myself excited to blog about (I’d be blogging about HIMYM right now if not for having to appeal to the masses), but I figure the idea of House managing to (of all things) diagnose a tumour through a television screen is perhaps worth a look. That it is a soap star works that much better, as House’s best possible persona is a hilarious, overbearing, and fanboyish doctor who is willing to go way, way too far.

After last week was definitely a study in character, this time it’s a study in humour – before we reach the end of the first act, he’s kidnapped, sedated, lied to and dragged future storyline details out of his favourite soap star, and in the process much laughter from the viewer. But with the end of the season looming, there’s the issue of ensuring that the storyline featuring our new diagnosticians is resolved – did it do enough to move forward that storyline even with this comic structure?

The answer is yes, even if it didn’t seem it at first.

Continue reading →

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

May 5, 2008 · 12:12 pm

Brothers & Sisters – “Moral Hazard”

“Moral Hazard”

May 4th, 2008

There is no storyline in television more hazardous at the moment than the fatal attraction of Justin Walker and Rebecca Not-Walker. It is an incredibly dangerous storyline for the series to engage at this point in time, but the real hazard is very simple: it’s actually really entertaining to watch.

Way too entertaining, too – Dave Annable and Emily VanCamp are both fantastic, and the scenes in the episode that deal with this issue fly around in a way that is humorous enough to make me forget the huge psychological ramifications at play. Based on these scenes, the show clearly understands the dangers they face and are willing to take the right steps to make it work.

That’s not to say it’s not still frakkin’ creepy, but it’s not quite as reprehensible as it could have been.

Continue reading →

1 Comment

Filed under Brothers & Sisters

Tagged as , , ,

May 2, 2008 · 11:06 pm

Battlestar Galactica – “The Road Less Traveled”

“The Road Less Traveled”

May 2nd, 2008

After last week threw us into the psychological and religious conflict brewing on Galactica, it’s natural that this takes a back seat to the plots we really want to see: Starbuck’s struggles to find Earth and the Cylon’s internal conflict. We’re thrown right into the action this time around, with Mark Verheiden’s script starting with a definitive revelation for the Demetrius.

That was what was lacking last week, as to an extent “Escape Velocity” seems unnecessary by comparison: here, we get the kinds of reactions that we expected to find last week but didn’t. We get a glimpse of Baltar, and one that perhaps didn’t need such an extracted investigation as we saw last week. Similarly, did we really need last week’s events to explain Tyrol shaving his head and obsessing over his wife’s death? I liked last week’s episode alright, but it feels as if it was a lot of exposition without much comparative value.

Last week felt totally wrong when it comes to the central conceit of the season: the blurring of the line between human and Cylon is integral to defining the series moving forward, and this week we return to the concepts of shared destiny and identity within the context of the series. The result is a sharper episode, one that feels like we are, indeed, traveling down a particular road as the two storylines missing last week coincide.

Continue reading →

Leave a comment

Filed under Battlestar Galactica

Tagged as , , ,

May 2, 2008 · 5:26 pm

Grey’s Anatomy – “Piece of My Heart”

“Piece of My Heart”

May 1st, 2008

It’s certain: we have missed Addison Montgomery. I never got into Private Practice, a show that I found too preachy and too talkative for its own good (A comment that Addison makes when trying to discern things from glances and eyebrow raises instead of the long-winded speeches of LA). This is a show that, for too long, has been decipherable: these characters have been acting out of character, scrambling around and struggling without really coming out and saying it.

Well, they’re coming out and saying it now: often it only takes one new influence for things to perk up, and Addison Montgomery is that character. It’s a cheap plot device on the surface, sure, but we create a sense of drama that we haven’t seen in a year. Something about her arrival, and the surgeries that surround it, influences our characters across the board. She is the person that they can talk to, someone who won’t be around for the drama and who wants to know how things will change.

The result is some great character turns, some drama being drawn from humanity and not chaos, and an emotionally charged hour of television.

Continue reading →

Leave a comment

Filed under Grey's Anatomy

Tagged as , , ,

May 2, 2008 · 12:42 pm

The Office – “Did I Stutter?”

“Did I Stutter?”

May 1st, 2008

I’m in the process of preparing an article for Always Watching on what I consider to be one of the Office’s most definitive qualities, and I am always glad to see when something pops up to prove my point for me. In this instance, “Did I Stutter?” manages to portray a version of the Office where no one is an abject idiot, and things which were funny without being sensationalist or over-the-top. It was the best possible argument for a version of this series, and its characters, which resists caricature in favour of subtle, yet brilliant, development.

A lot of this is dependent on the version of Michael Scott that we see, and here he is at his most naive, desperate and yet also honest – this is a Michael Scott who of course doesn’t know how to handle an employee being insubordinate, but when tasked with addressing the problem searches for advice and inevitably comes across a decent, if eventually overused solution.

And if The Office can be both funny and logical while maintaining this characterization, I’m on board.

Continue reading →

Leave a comment

Filed under The Office

Tagged as , , ,

May 1, 2008 · 10:40 pm

30 Rock – “Sandwich Day”

“Sandwich Day”

May 1st, 2008

If there was something that I was missing in the first batch of post-strike episodes of 30 Rock, it was whimsy: while there was plenty of humour, there were few instances where the show was moving at the same pace that it had in the past. It hasn’t been poor, not at all, but this was the first time that things were moving at the same speed as we’ve seen before.

This week, everything just felt lighter: Liz felt more silly (in a good way), Jack felt more panicked, and the storylines felt like they were on a level that matched the usual madness of the storylines. To this point, it felt like the plots didn’t match the tone, and here we are with an episode that seems right.

That’s not to say it’s better than what we’ve seen: Floyd’s return pales in comparison to Dennis’, there was nothing close to last week’s expanded Amadeus metaphor, and the drinking contest storyline was fairly slight compared to some of the others we’ve seen. However, it was a breezy and enjoyable half hour nonetheless.

Continue reading →

2 Comments

Filed under 30 Rock

Tagged as , ,

May 1, 2008 · 9:27 pm

Lost – “Something Nice Back Home”

“Something Nice Back Home”

May 1st, 2008

Welcome to May, folks, and welcome to yet another new episode of Lost. If the trend continues, this week has the potential to upend last week’s momentum: if there’s ever a way to stop plot development in its tracks, the past has shown that Jack and Kate episodes are the most effective. So, when we flashforward to a time when Kate and Jack are in angsty situations, there are signs that we might be in the wrong territory.

But then, things got interesting: it wasn’t a Jack story at all. You start to realize that although Jack is the window into our flashforward and this episode, this isn’t about him: it’s about people haunted by their past, and haunted by its impact on their lives. Where is home for these people, when all of them are struggling to reconcile their new lives with haunting flashbacks from their past?

There’s a lot of questions this episode, and while they might not be as game-changing as last week they remain dramatically strong and certainly important to developing these characters as we march towards a finale.

WARNING: Spoilers, so don’t be clicking until you’ve watched it, or until you’ve decided to turn to the dark side.

Continue reading →

5 Comments

Filed under Lost

Tagged as , , ,