Category Archives: The Office

The Office: Commodity or Television Show?

As a fan of good television, I am a fan of The Office. Greg Daniels and Co. have done a fantastic job taking the British series and making a relevant, funny, and memorable comedy. Combined with 30 Rock, it means one hell of a Thursday night, which is in every viewer’s best interest. For me, the series is a television show worth watching, and one that I want to see succeed.

For those who may have read my posts about the start of the show’s fourth season, you likely saw that I had some problems. I felt that the one-hour episodes were almost all failures at sustaining comedy and character, and that even when the show returned with half hours it was missing something. It was still memorable, but there were some fundamental problems that I felt needed more attention – not in a total overhaul sense, but just some small-scale adjustments.

However, I am not convinced NBC views The Office as a television show anymore – they’ve scheduled another batch of one-hour episodes for the start of next season, a move made on money and ratings and little else. I know that the show is a rare demographic star for the network, but milking it like this didn’t do it any good from a creative sense. And, maybe it’s that I don’t have a bottom line to worry about, but isn’t that the most important thing?

It doesn’t appear to be for NBC, because now comes word that starting in February The Office will be paired with a spinoff, a series built from the existing stable of characters and a host of new ones. This is being sold as a good thing, a chance for the unsung heroes of the large ensemble cast to get their due. And, on the one hand, I agree with this enthusiastic if questionable response: I think there some characters in The Office deserve more time to shine, if you will. However, I can’t help but ask the question of why this spinoff is really necessary, and why NBC thinks now is the best time.

When to run a spinoff is a tricky gambit, one that has multiple options.

Continue reading

4 Comments

Filed under The Office

An Open Letter to NBC, Re: Fall 2008 Schedule

Dearest NBC,

According to the trades, you have revealed your Fall schedule, which is one of those times when I head off to Variety to ponder what kind of stupid decisions you’ve made. Now, you’re right – you have occasionally made some good decisions, and there are some of them found within this year’s announcement. However, at the same time, there are some which frustrate me to no end, and which need to be discussed.

First, let’s discuss the good:

  • Friday Night Lights is definitely coming back, although not until the Winter. Through some sort of cost-saving measure (Hopefully not cutting out parts of the ensemble, although I could do with less Lyla in general), the show has been saved – long live quality television.
  • On the same front, unsurprising considering its buzz in critical circles, 30 Rock is returning for a third season. After such a creative push pre-strike, it should be interesting to see how it does in the post-strike period. Hopefully, like How I Met Your Mother, it will see a boost.
  • A smart network, “Thursday Night Live” will air for four weeks leading up to the Presidential Election following The Office on Thursday Night. This shall offer some strong comedy, which excites me.
  • NBC is officially not picking up Scrubs, a great decision in my books. Too bad ABC wishes to flog the dead horse a while longer.
  • Critical hit Life, even with low ratings, is renewed as previously announced, but might struggle for viewers on Friday nights in the Winter.

Now, based on this you’d think that I was happy with this upfront, that I wouldd have just posted about how great you were, NBC, and move on with my life. Well, let’s just say that I have some other issues – I won’t get into your new shows (Not much information is available, and what little there is doesn’t tickle my fancy to be honest), but there are a few decisions you’ve made that are potentially awful:

  • Airing after the Super Bowl, NBC is officially launching a spinoff of The Office. Now, this is only a potential evil: I haven’t seen the show, and no details are available as of this time. However, I’ll have more thoughts throughout the week on why I think this is a fairly volatile idea.
  • However, that’s not even the biggest concern with the Office – that belongs to the idiotic return to one-hour episodes in the Fall. I’ll rant more about this later too, but do we not remember those episodes? And how they were not up to the standards of the half-hours which proceeded? Did no one at NBC pay attention to the quality of the show in this decision? Clearly, they did not.

What these decisions represent to be is a shameless milking, a milking that goes against the quality of a television program. I think there is potential for an Office spinoff (I vote for Daryl, personally), but I don’t know if the show proper is at a place creatively where it will be able to excise part of itself. I guess that your confidence in The Office financially doesn’t quite jive with my own views of its relative quality this season, which is fine…I just wish you’d just kept it at a half hour. I could deal with spinoff, but the two combined just angers me.

I shall vent more anger tomorrow, so stay tuned. Plus, knowing you, you’ll have changed this schedule by then.

Sincerely,

Myles

1 Comment

Filed under The Office

10 Shows to (Hopefully) Watch in 2008: #10-8

Cultural Learnings’ 10 Shows to (Hopefully) Watch in 2008 is a list which reflects not the best series to possibly air in the calendar year, but rather those which shall prove most interesting to watch both in terms of the show itself and the buzz surrounding it. Some shows have made this list due to curiosity, hype, or a genuine interest in their creative future. Some of these shows may not air a single new episode of television until the fall, but it’s never too early to look ahead. On with the list!

Last year, I designated an episode of Heroes (“Company Man”) as the #1 episode of television during February Sweeps, and perhaps during the entire year. Ultimately, I’d probably give that distinction to an episode from another series, but the fact remains that Heroes did some great things in the past year that should make them something to watch in 2008. Unfortunately, almost all of that goodwill has been squandered.

As a result, Heroes barely makes this list due to a sheer curiosity as to how low Tim Kring and Co. can sink this ship. If the season one finale took the wind out of its sails, the show’s “Volume Two” was a shipwreck of epic proportions. Everything that went wrong did: new characters fell flat, beloved characters were stuck in awful storylines, and there was no “Company Man” to save a sinking ship.

Before the last few episodes of Season Two, I was at least optimistic that Tim Kring’s apology would at least ensure that the series would right itself heading into Volume Three. However, what Kring sold us as an altered course was still in a fundamentally wrong direction, and an awful fall finale was enough for Heroes to become entertaining not due to its quality but due to its continue descent into mediocrity. If I’m watching in 2008, it will only be out of a morbid curiosity…and that’s kind of sad.

Heroes will not go back into production until the Writers’ Strike is resolved. Chances are it will complete its 22-episode second season with a string of 11 episodes to air in the fall of 2008.

YouTube: Heroes Volume Three Preview

I feel obligated to place one of the season’s midseason debuts on the list, but don’t view this as a token selection – Terminator: Sarah Connor Chronicles is perhaps one of the most interesting drama series to hit the airwaves this year. This attempt at spinning off the Terminator franchise seems a terrible idea on paper, but its execution is solid: the pilot presents a level of action and drama that at the very least appears to offer a smarter and more cohesive alternative to NBC’s fading sci-fi series.

Continue reading

1 Comment

Filed under Heroes, Terminator: Sarah Connor Chronicles, The Office

30 Rock – “Somebody to Love” and The Office – “The Deposition”

“Somebody to Love”

November 15th, 2007

If tonight’s episode of 30 Rock taught me anything, it’s two things: first, that Edie Falco really isn’t that funny. And, on a more positive note, training for the Amazing Race really does make you look like a terrorist.

The episode’s storyline featuring Liz freaking out over her Middle Eastern neighbour (Played by the always awesome Fred Armisen) was pretty dull until the reveal that as opposed to planning a terrorist attack he was audition for the Amazing Race. Armisen was great in the role, but the storyline took the focus away from the running of a television network. And, while the show can still be funny in this mode, it paled in comparison.

Jack’s storyline had the same problem, with Edie Falco playing a Democratic Congresswoman who meets Jack and starts a clandestine affair even when she is directly fighting environmental pollution by the Sheinhardt Wig Company. Falco wasn’t that funny, and the only great stuff to come out of the storyline was a TV movie (See below) and Tracy’s pick-up line selections at the end of the episode.

Kenneth had a sidestory about losing Jack’s pants and becoming a monkey for the writing staff, but it never clicked. After a few weeks of really fantastic episodes, this was definitely a step backward for the series. Still, there was some funny stuff, and I can’t possibly dislike a good Amazing Race reference.

Cultural Observations

  • “That’s an antique, and I’m a white lady!” and “Remember when I asked that black guy if he saw Sideways?” were a quick, yet funny, departure into sketchy subjects from Liz.
  • I loved Kenneth’s sign for Jack’s pants: “A Pair of Fancy Tuxedo Pants”. Oh Kenneth.
  • My far the best part of Edie Falco’s cameo was the Lifetime Movie resulting from her tragic past: “A Dog Took My Face, and Gave Me a Better Face, So I Could Change the World: The Celeste Cunningham Story.” Kristen Wiig did great with the scenes, a highlight for the episode.
  • Oh, and Jack singing “What the World Needs Now (Is Love)” was also kind of great in a more subtle way.
  • Oddly, neither of the episode’s two main storylines really resolved themselves: are Falco and Armisen sticking around? Also, Jenna was noticeably absent…I know it might just be me, but I kind of missed her?

“The Deposition”

November 15th, 2007

Following a pattern of the past few weeks, “The Deposition” dealt with inter-office shenanigans and Michael’s storyline in very separate fashions. While the employees enjoy what essentially boils down to fun and games, Michael actually had a lot of serious weight to his storyline this week.

And I like that: living up to last week’s Michael and Jim conversation, the show let Michael have a mature storyline that while still hilarious managed to actually hold some levity. With Michael and Jan’s relationship on trial, and the ping-pong championship at stake in Scranton, both worlds were well represented in an even-handed segment…that will sadly be the last we get for awhile.

Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under 30 Rock, The Office

30 Rock – “Greenzo” and The Office – “Survivor Man”

NBC’s Green Week has been largely unsuccessful at actually convincing me they care about the environment, but last night my two favourite NBC shows joined the fray. While neither were entirely overrun by their environmental theming, I would argue that one was largely more successful than the other.

“Greenzo”

November 8th, 2007

This episode of 30 Rock has officially proven that Tina Fey’s series is perhaps the most versatile on television at this moment. Between the character of Jack Donaghy, the television network construct and a smart use of self-referential humour, the show effortlessly takes a theme and turns it into a sharp and succinct episode of television.

What I love is that, despite being forced to commit to a weekly NBC theming, the episode actually had the largest contribution from the supporting cast thus far this season. Kenneth’s party was a great way for us to get to see that this is actually, you know, a cast and crew of a TV show; it’s surrealistic turn at the end of the episode was just the right conclusion, especially because of Jack’s awesome, awesome hair.

The environmental storyline hit the right spot – David Schwimmer was good as Greenzo, Al Gore’s cameo was well-handled, and the aggressive tone Greenzo took was just the kind of mean streak I like to see from the show sometimes. It felt like just another strong 30 Rock episode that just happened to tell us about the environment.

Favourite Lines

  • “It combines my two favourite things: Boxing and Referees!” – Tracy on Foxy Boxing
  • “What do you do with the pop tart?!” – Liz making me dislike Pop Tarts more
  • “I don’t understand what’s happening!” – Kenneth
  • “Shhh…a whale is in trouble!” – Al Gore selling the line like a champ
  • “This earth is ruined, we gotta get a new one” – Liz when the Earth is…set on fire.

“Survivor Man”

November 8th, 2007

I’ve been watching some Survivorman recently, the TV show where a crazy guy goes out into the Amazon or some other dangerous location with only a match, a few things he can MacGyver, and his own crazy self. But, I now imagine a world where said crazy man left behind a dysfunctional group of characters who just weren’t the same without him. Not only was Michael Scott’s foray into the woods largely not that funny (except for Dwight), but Jim’s time alone in the office just wasn’t as sharp as it could be.

Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under 30 Rock, The Office

The Office – “Branch Wars”

“Branch Wars”

November 1st, 2007

This week signals a return to the type of Office episode that I enjoy, find humorous, and yet can’t help but feel could have been better. I like this kind of episode, because it isn’t bad (Which at least one of the one hour segments were) and it signals a return to formula for a series that deviated from it too often early in the season.

Strongly directed by returning guest director Joss Whedon (Who is returning to television with Fox next year), the episode had some great subtle visual comedy and a great awkward moment between Jim and Karen (Returning guest star Rashida Jones). However, the build to that moment was The Office at a sensationalist level that did not elicit enough laughs to justify its stupidity.

And, I’m sorry, but urine is always stupid.

Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under The Office

The Office – “Launch Day”

“Launch Day”

October 11th, 2007

To expand on the cold open to tonight’s episode of The Office, the show is a little square bouncing around a TV screen. As a fan, I’ve been watching to see whether the series will be able to hit that sweet spot right in the corner of the screen. As the members of the office wait for the bouncing cube to finally enter into that elusive meeting place of perpindicular lines, something happens: it goes in the corner. And, as if to coincide, the show found its own corner as well.

What the show brought to the table this week, that it hasn’t in weeks past, is a focus on entirely Office-related activity. The show teased heading to New York, but staying grounded in Scranton brought out the best in the show’s characters. The episode wasn’t perfect: the second half still devolved into Michael’s crazy antics that went a tad too far, but it remained grounded in the office environment. Plus, Michael actually realized he had done something wrong: a step in the right direction!

Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under The Office

The Office – “Dunder Mifflin Infinity”

“Dunder Mifflin Infinity”

October 4th, 2007

Dwight thinks they could do better, Angela thinks it’s fitting since Pam’s the office “mattress”, Andy’s happy to be the sexiest single guy in the office, and Michael thinks it is a life-changing event. The Jim and Pam union is officially known to the office, and the office reaction is clear. However, they continue to take a backseat to other focuses: Ryan’s return to the office is the big story this week, and I couldn’t be happier.

Why? Because Ryan dealing with an obvious lack of authority within the Scranton environment is a unique and new situation for the series. The transition from office temp to corporate boss, having to present a new-age Dunder Mifflin Infinity internet overhaul (NBC’s Meta site can be found at DunderMifflinInfinity.com), is an incredibly tough sell when you have Kelly dressing scantily, Creed feeling pushed out, and the pita fire still haunting his past. The theme of the week is change, and it leads to an episode that feels more integrated and natural than last week’s…until its conclusion.

Continue reading

1 Comment

Filed under The Office

Season Premiere: The Office – “Fun Run”

“Fun Run”

September 27th, 2007

I would like to make two observations about this highly anticipated fourth season premiere of The Office. First, I would argue that “fun” is not a proper descriptor for the episode’s events: while certainly with its funny moments, it felt overlong and tired compared to some of the show’s more engaging and classic episodes. The second is that despite this fact, millions of viewers are likely to be so satisfied by the “Jam” (Or PB&J as Kevin calls them) developments that none of that will matter.

I’m far too cynical to avoid pointing out the episode’s issues, but can we talk about how adorable Pam and Jim were in this episode? Whether it’s their secret glances, their secret rendezvous or their secret estate-sale browsing, their secret affair was the part of the episode that felt most fresh and, importantly, interesting. I care about these two people, as irrational as that may be, and I liked that the show used its documentary format to slowly reveal the relationship through the hour.

But there were other story threads I was interested in following following the show’s third season premiere. I wanted to see how newly unemployed and psychotic Jan changed Michael’s life, and how newly promoted Ryan would play a role in the affairs of The Office. I was also curious to see how Karen’s reaction to Jim’s post-New York singlehood would affect the show’s core relationships. However, this hour barely touched on these issues, focusing instead on hijinx and another key relationship.

Continue reading

2 Comments

Filed under Television, The Office

Cultural Learnings’ Fall 2007 Lineup: Thursdays

Yes, I am aware that there was a delay in posting Thursday’s lineup, but there was a reason for this. I’ve been anxious over this day in particular because, as per usual, it remains the most packed night of programming on the Fall Schedule, especially for me. And last night, I decided to see whether I might (finally) be able to cut Survivor out of my Thursday lineup. And, well, see below for whether or not that worked.

The Office

Airing four hour long episodes early in the season before Scrubs premieres, The Office is taking on Grey’s Anatomy single-handedly this year. It hopes to sustain last year’s ratings, and certainly has a decent shot at it. There’s some exciting developments heading into this season (Ryan as the boss, Jim/Pam, etc.), so even some uneven episodes won’t keep me away.

Cultural Learnings’ Review of The Office Finale 

30 Rock

This Emmy-winning comedy has the unfortunate circumstance of being located within a rather difficult timeslot: sure, it belonged to The Office last year, but it’s also against two other shows I’m interested in covering. Still, it gets this particular spot regardless of that development: the show was too good last season to consider putting on the backburner, although it doesn’t debut for a while yet.

Cultural Learnings’ 30 Rock Coverage 

Survivor: China

Yeah, I’m weak: as much as I might claim I can disconnect from this series in its 15th season, it just isn’t happening this time around. The cast of characters have already had a chance to make their impact, and the challenges despite repetition are usually enough to suck me in. I’ve tended to skip the Tribal Council sequences more now, but the point stands: I’m covering Survivor.

Cultural Learnings’ Survivor Coverage 

The Other Shows

Ugly Betty and Grey’s Anatomy are in a tough spot for me, one in terms of time period and the other due to a weak third season. Ugly Betty ended its first season on a high note, and certainly has a lot of momentum moving forward. But I never feel like I’m “caught up” in it, which is the way I perhaps felt about Grey’s Anatomy before a frustrating last stanza. The George/Izzie relationship took out a lot of steam, so it’s going to be wait and see for the series.

I’ll also be watching Scrubs when it returns late in the year, although my interest in that series has also wained.

Leave a comment

Filed under 2007 Fall Preview, 30 Rock, ABC, Grey's Anatomy, NBC, Reality TV, Scrubs, Survivor, Television, The Office, Ugly Betty