November 23, 2013 · 12:18 am
My biggest issues with the Hunger Games trilogy were both things that have gone unchanged in the film adaptations. The structural sameness of the three books may have had a purpose, but it particularly affected my enjoyment of the second book, Catching Fire, where it felt lazy and formulaic rather than meaningful. The same can be said for the books’ close first-person perspective, which I found particularly limiting in the glimpses of a bigger conflict in Catching Fire that the perspective gave the books no chance to explore.
What I found most interesting about my response to The Hunger Games: Catching Fire, Francis Lawrence’s adaptation of what I identified as the least successful of the novels back in 2011, is that I liked it much more than its predecessor despite the fact it doubles down on these elements. Some of this has to do with how “first-person perspectives” function differently in literature vs. film, certainly, but I think it’s also a case in which one of the film’s most potentially frustrating choices successfully neutralizes one of the book’s biggest problems.
[Spoilers for the film, and then separately marked spoilers for the series, follow]
Continue reading →
Filed under Cinema
Tagged as /Film, Adaptation, Analysis, Catching Fire, Francis Lawrence, Katniss, Novel, Quarter Quell, Review, Suzanne Collins, The Hunger Games: Catching Fire
June 7, 2011 · 1:36 am
I think Twitter was the main reason I chose to read Suzanne Collins’ Hunger Games trilogy.
No, it wasn’t because my followers on Twitter suggested I read the books, or that a person I follow recommended them at large. Instead, I was becoming completely unglued at every sight of the never-ending casting announcements for the upcoming film adaptation of the first book in the series, The Hunger Games, coming in the Spring. More than any other film in recent memory, it seemed as though every single role was a piece of news, and I became too curious to resist diving into the series.
A few weeks later, I emerged with an understanding for the books’ appeal and a large pile of critical thoughts that I’m itching to discuss with other folks who have read the books. Although I rarely dive into literature around these parts (although this will likely not be the first time this summer that I do so), I figured that this is as good a place as any to consider what makes the series distinct, what makes the series an ultimate disappointment, and why I’m extremely curious to see how they plan to adapt this story given some of its particular qualities.
Spoilers for the entire Hunger Games Trilogy follow.
Continue reading →
Filed under Cultural Reading
Tagged as /Film, Adaptation, Analysis, Books, Catching Fire, Darkness, First Person, Gale, Hunger Games Trilogy, Katniss, Literature, Media, Mockingjay, Narrative, Novels, Peeta, President Snow, Propos, Television, The Arena, The Hunger Games, Young Adult