May 19, 2010 · 12:48 pm
Critics Ponder “What They Died For”
May 19th, 2010
Trapped between perhaps the most divisive episode in the show’s history and a sprawling two and a half hour finale shrouded in mystery, “What They Died For” is a bit tough to “criticize.” Generally speaking, the episode was dramatically strong and effective at providing momentum heading into the finale, but with no guarantees that the payoff will live up to our expectations there is this sense of uncertainty which means that this weeks reviews from critics are sort of hedging their bets.
Normally, you might claim this is in some way counterproductive, but it means that critics are focused on making connections to past episodes and offering their own takes on how the developments in this episode apply to larger ideas within Lost as a whole. It makes for another strong week of Lost criticism, as the setup work done in “What They Died For” is mirrored by critics setting up their own perspectives on the series as we head into Sunday’s finale.
So, let’s take a journey around the internet to see what the critics are saying, shall we?
Continue reading →
Filed under Lost
Tagged as ABC, Across the Sea, Analysis, Carlton Cuse, Characters, Choice, Critics, Damon Lindelof, Desmond, Episode 16, Heroism, Jack, Jacob, Mad Men, Narrative, Quest Narrative, Reviews, Roundup, Sawyer, Season 3, Season 6, Television, Themes, TV
April 28, 2010 · 12:29 am
April 27th, 2010
“I don’t try to change you, you don’t try to change me”
There is nothing I hate more than a show doing everything I ask it to and nonetheless leaves me cold. If you had asked me to focus on some of the prevailing problems to this point in Glee’s Spring season, I would have pointed to the narrow storylines which tend to focus on the central love triangles rather than the supporting characters, so to have an episode that so clearly focuses on characters like Kurt and Mercedes seems like it should be right up my alley.
The problem with “Home” is that it feels like the show is being changed rather than changing, characters emerging from their prison of one-dimensionality and returning to the last time they had anything close to character development. At times this results in beautiful musical numbers and emotionally resonant scenes which speak to the larger series, but as an actual episode “Home” feels equal parts honest and dishonest thanks to the sense that none of it has been earned from a narrative perspective.
You could make the same argument about “Wheels,” I realize this, but I think that this episode contained more of both sides of the show’s schizophrenia as it relates to certain characters, and comes directly after an episode which presented such wildly different versions of these characters that the jarring lack of continuity cannot be overcome by an emotional performance of a Burt Bacharach song, no matter how hard the show tries to make it so.
Continue reading →
Filed under Glee
Tagged as A House is Not a Home, Amber Riley, Analysis, April Rhodes, Ashes, Beautiful, Bruce Springsteen, Burt Bacharach, Change, Characters, Cheerios, Chris Colfer, Episode 15, Finn, Fire, FOX, Home, Kristin Chenoweth, Matthew Morrison, Mercedes, Mike O'Malley, Music, Review, Roller Rink, Sue Sylvester, Television, The Wiz, TV, Weight, Will Schuester
February 21, 2009 · 3:52 am
February 20th, 2009
When Joss Whedon first introduced the concept of Dollhouse, the show had potential largely based on its philosophical ideas, examining who these actives were, who they are now, and who they could potentially be in the future. In the show’s ostensible pilot of sorts, “Ghost,” we only really dealt with these questions on a surface level: we saw an example of the kind of job that Echo could be given, and a small glimpse into who she once was. But that middle question was left more or less unanswered: while we got some sense of complications with the actives and potential hazards, the philosophical questions (morality, ethics, all of that jazz) were never really investigated.
This is the reason why I’m not sure why “The Target” wasn’t the show’s pilot, because with a little bit more introduction to the key values this is a far more interesting hour of television. Not only was Echo’s “case of the week” far more interesting to watch, but the stakes were higher, and more importantly the people whose lives were at stake were people that we were supposed to care about. This episode, using Boyd’s first days at Dollhouse as a framework, show us a side of Dollhouse that is morally questionable, that raises some important questions both about the security of this process and the transparency of Dollhouse’s leadership, and does a lot more to make me excited about this show and its characters than last week’s comparatively pedestrian offering.
Continue reading →
Filed under Dollhouse
Tagged as Alpha, Amy Acker, Boyd, Characters, Dr. Saunders, Echo, Eliza Dushku, Entertainment, Episode 2, FOX, Green Screen, Harry Lennix, Joss Whedon, Matt Keeslar, Procedural, Season 1, Tahmoh Penikett, Television, The Middleman, The Target