July 23, 2010 · 12:28 am
The Irony of Monotony: Why SYTYCD’s Season of Reinvention Still Feels Stale
July 22nd, 2010
Earlier in the seventh season of So You Think You Can Dance, I commented at length on how the All-Star structure seemed to take away some of my favourite parts of the series, including seeing the contestants develop chemistry as a team and working together to overcome challenging choreography. However, as the season has gone on, the show was willing to break up the All-Star format to allow the dancers to pair up with each other, which helped bring some of that chemistry back to the table even if we didn’t get to see it develop over the weeks.
And yet, I think that the structure of the season has run into another roadblock tonight: when I heard word that they had chosen to send no one home, sparing an injured Billy Bell and a struggling Jose from their potential exits, I realized that the show’s biggest problem this season is how monotonous it has become. Sure, I’m not the kind of fan who has that moment of relief when my favourite is saved and gets to dance another day, but the biggest problem with So You Think You Can Dance this season is that even with all of the various reinventions I’m getting really tired of seeing these people dance.
Which I think is more of a reflection of the way the season has been structured than a reflection of the dancers themselves.
Continue reading →
Filed under So You Think You Can Dance
Tagged as All-Stars, Analysis, Billy Bell, Double Elimination, Elimination, Kenny Ortega, Monotony, Nigel Lythgoe, Reality Competition, Reality TV, Review, SYTYCD, Tabitha and Napoleon, Television, Top 6, Twitch, Voting
October 25, 2009 · 8:59 pm
Who Won SYTYCD Canada Season 2?
October 25th, 2009
Since I’ve been home this year, and since it has as a result been on every Tuesday evening, I’ve been following So You Think You Can Dance Canada where I didn’t last year. What I’ve discovered is that this is a show that can be really engaging for the reasons that any dancing competition show is, but that it constantly claims to be something “different.” It’s a weird cultural superiority scenario, wherein the mosaic we like to consider ourselves part of is somehow reflected by the decision to classify genres of dance more distinctly or how what the American show is claiming as progress (Tap Dancers! Krumpers!) was already achieved this season in Canada. The judges, as I ranted about early on during the competitive rounds, are also far too nice, often failing to critique routines that deserve some sort of constructive feedback.
It’s all part of the reason why I found tonight’s finale anti-climactic, as its celebratory tone was not that different from the self-congratulation that defines the show. I don’t think the show is misplaced in thinking itself to be entertaining or valuable to the development of Canadian dance, but there’s a point where that becomes the “point” of the show. And the result is that I actually don’t think we’ve spent enough time with these contestants for me to really suggest I am invested in them, or for that matter that the show is invested in them. The finale only further cements this fact, with some strange (if not entirely unjustified) approaches that indicate once and for all that this is not a show about dance so much as it is about how Canada is so uniquely situated to host a show about dance.
And tonight, Canada picked their ambassador.
Continue reading →
Filed under So You Think You Can Dance Canada
Tagged as Back Injury, Canada, Canada's Favourite Dancer, Choreographers, CTV, Dance, Entertainment, Everett, Injuries, Jayme Rae, Judges, Kenny Ortega, Leah Miller, Mia Michaels, Reality TV, Results, Season Finale, Spoilers, Stacey Tookey, Tara-Jean, Tara-Jean Popowich, Television, Top 10, Top 20, Top 4, Vincent, Winner