“The Pointy End”
June 5th, 2011
“Written by George R.R. Martin”
The credits for Game of Thrones has always read “Created by David Benioff and D.B. Weiss,” but the question of authorship has always been considerably more complicated. The fact is that this is very clearly George R.R. Martin’s world, and George R.R. Martin’s characters, and even George R.R. Martin’s story – while we can certainly argue that Benioff and Weiss have taken certain liberties, adding scenes and shifting character allegiances, it has not utterly transformed Martin’s vision. And yet, at the same time, we can’t say that this is Martin’s show, as he was ancillary to the myriad of decisions which move beyond the initial creation to the execution and design. A Song of Ice and Fire may be his story, but Game of Thrones is not his television show, and there’s an odd shared ownership of Westeros that has been evident throughout the season.
I say evident, mind you, and not problematic. The scenes that have been added have been strong, and the decisions made have been mostly logical if not necessarily ideal in every instance (or for every fan). However, here you have an instance where the person doing the adaptation is Martin himself, given a chance to return to key moments and characters and tell the same story all over again. And yet, he’s now working within someone else’s show even when he’s working within his own story, an intriguing scenario that I thought going in might make for an intriguing case study.
However, there’s honestly nothing to really see here: while this is a very strong outing, and maintains the momentum from last week’s episode quite brilliantly even as it hits the fast forward button on the narrative action (and thus risks missing key pieces of the puzzle), I don’t think we see some sort of crisis of authorship. Martin’s return coincides with the period where exposition goes out the window, and where major story events are starting to take shape. It is a period where characters are making decisions instead of pondering them, and where key themes are beginning to filter throughout the storylines at a rapid pace, and so any authorship is swallowed up by the sheer presence of the realm and those outside its borders who threaten it.
In other words, it’s just as Martin intended it, and thus as Benioff and Weiss intended it as well.
Continue reading →
Filed under Game of Thrones
Tagged as Analysis, Arya, Authorship, Bran, Catelyn, Cersei, D.B. Weiss, Dany, David Benioff, Dothraki, Entertainment, Episode 8, George R.R. Martin, Greatjon, HBO, Hodor, Joffrey, Jon Snow, Narrative, Ned Stark, Pacing, Point of View, Review, Robb, Sansa, Season 1, Ser Barristan Selmy, Shagga, Syrio, Television, The Pointy End, The Wall, Time, TV, Tyrion, Varys, Westeros, Wights, Zombies
Cultural Learnings 