October 4, 2011 · 8:01 pm
October 4th, 2011
You’re going to read a lot of reviews of “Asian F” which reference its problematic elements, and they are all correct. Will and Emma’s storyline, in particular, is one of those instances where a serious subject is treated as dramatic without being treated seriously, with bizarre caricatures (Emma’s parents) mixing with some problematic characterization (with Will offering to fix Emma, basically). While I’m glad the show isn’t created obstacles for the couple on a macro scale, regressing Emma is not particularly productive, and the entire storyline felt like it was happening in a different show entirely.
Of course, this isn’t uncommon for Glee. In fact, “Asian F” as a whole sort of exists in these different shows, simultaneously indulging in introspective looks at particular characters (Mike and Mercedes), large-scale numbers (Brittany’s “Run the World (Girls)” and the group sing of “Fix You”), and even some storyline continuity with the casting of West Side Story. In truth, there is little to no cohesion in these storylines, and their effectiveness is decidedly mixed, and yet I still think “Asian F” is a strong step forward for the show.
At the very least, it indicates that Glee is willing to try things, which is a good thing even if they don’t particularly work.
Continue reading →
Filed under Glee
Tagged as Amber Riley, Analysis, Asian F, Dreamgirls, Effie White, Episode 3, Lea Michele, Mercedes, Mike Chang, Rachel, Review, Riff, Season 3, Television, TV
October 12, 2010 · 9:30 pm
October 12th, 2010
I’ve talked a lot about the “Three Glees” theory in the past (TM Todd VanDerWerff), where each of the three co-creators have a different perspective on the series. However, in most instances we focus on the whiplash between the various different episodes, a sort of multiple personality disorder, but what I don’t think we’ve theorized on as much is the way in which these Glees comment on one another. I think this was because, before “Duets,” I don’t think there had ever been an episode of the show which so clearly commented on the work of one of the other writers.
Since the show is basically serialized, there is always an element of connection between the episodes, but “Duets” offers direct commentary on both long-term characterizations and specific events from “Theatricality,” an episode which I had some serious problems with earlier in the year. Ian Brennan, scripting his first episode since the premiere, has created an episode which adds unseen depth to previous storylines, makes pretty substantial strides with characters both old and new, and in the process convinces me that in a scenario where one writer is to take over the series, Brennan is without question the show’s white knight.
“Duets” is not the most daring episode of the series, but it is unquestionably the most consistent, and that alone makes this one of the series’ finest hours.
Continue reading →
Filed under Glee
Tagged as Analysis, Artie, Barbra Streisand, Brittany, Burt Hummel, Chord Overstreet, Dianna Agron, Don't Go Breaking My Heart, Duets, Episode 4, Eric Stoltz, Finn, FOX, Harry Shum Jr., Ian Brennan, Judy Garland, Kurt, Le Jazz Hot, Lucky, Mercedes, Mike Chang, Mike O'Malley, Quinn, Review, River Deep Mountain High, Ryan Murphy, Sam Evans, Santana, Season 2, Sexuality, Sing!, Sue Sylvester, Television, Theatricality, Tina, TV, Virginity, Will, With You I'm Born Again, Writing